Hope for the Holidays | Part 2: Reframing Our Expectations
Have you ever put a great deal of time and energy into making Christmas special, only to find yourself disappointed when it was over?
The food was good, the decorations looked beautiful, and most of the family managed to show up. There were even some genuinely wonderful moments. Yet somewhere along the way, someone arrived late, another person seemed distracted, and a conversation you hoped would happen never quite materialized.
By the time the dishes were put away, you found yourself thinking more about what went wrong than what went right.
I've noticed something about experiences like that, both in my own life and through years of counseling. Sometimes our disappointment has less to do with what happened and more to do with the distance between our experience and our expectations.
Christmas seems particularly good at exposing that distance.
The Christmas We Carry in Our Heads
Most of us carry a picture of what Christmas ought to look like. Some of those images come from childhood, when the season seemed almost magical. We were blissfully unaware of how much work the adults were doing behind the scenes.
Others come from years when our children were young, our parents were still living, or everyone seemed a little closer. That closeness might have been geographical, relational, or both.
Those memories are precious, and there's nothing wrong with wanting to preserve meaningful traditions. The difficulty comes when we expect the present to reproduce the past, especially when the people and circumstances involved have changed.
Over the years, I've discovered that one small word can create an extraordinary amount of emotional pressure. That word is should.
The family should all be together. The children should appreciate the effort. Everyone should get along. And surely we should be able to make it through one holiday gathering without revisiting an argument that's been around longer than the Christmas decorations.
Now, I have nothing against reasonable expectations. We need them to plan our lives, maintain healthy relationships, and fulfill our responsibilities. But when our preferences quietly become demands, we begin placing the weight of our happiness on circumstances and people we cannot control.
That's a difficult way to live and an exhausting way to celebrate Christmas.
When Traditions Become Obligations
I enjoy Christmas traditions, particularly those connecting us to people and seasons of life we remember fondly. Familiar music can transport us back decades in seconds. A particular recipe can remind us of someone who hasn't sat at our table for years.
Even the decorations have stories attached to them. Although I suspect some of us have boxes in the garage containing ornaments whose stories we've long since forgotten.
Traditions can be wonderful gifts. But somewhere along the way, we can begin treating them as obligations that must be fulfilled regardless of the cost.
I've talked with people who were so determined to give their families a wonderful Christmas that they arrived at Christmas morning exhausted and irritated. They genuinely wanted to create meaningful memories. Unfortunately, the pressure to make everything just right had robbed them of much of the enjoyment they hoped to share.
I understand that tendency. When we care deeply about people, we naturally want things to go well. We want the gathering to be pleasant, the meal to be enjoyed, and the people we love to feel connected.
The problem is that we can prepare a gathering, but we cannot control the experience everyone brings to it. Each person arrives with a history, a personality, and perhaps a few concerns that have nothing to do with Christmas.
We can provide an opportunity for connection, but we cannot manufacture it.
When we confuse those two things, even a good Christmas can leave us feeling as though we've failed.
A Different Invitation
One passage I return to when thinking about expectations is Matthew 11:28–30. Jesus invites those who are weary and burdened to come to Him and find rest.
I encourage you to read the entire passage in context. The invitation is richer than simply telling tired people to take a break.
Jesus invites us to come under His care, learn from Him, and discover a different way of carrying life's responsibilities. His words weren't originally directed toward people planning Christmas celebrations, of course. But they speak powerfully to anyone weighed down by burdens they were never intended to carry.
I've spent much of my professional life helping people distinguish between what they can influence and what they cannot control. It's an important distinction, particularly in relationships.
We can communicate clearly, prepare thoughtfully, extend kindness, and make wise decisions. What we cannot do is guarantee how another person will respond, no matter how much we love them.
That reality doesn't release us from the responsibility to love well. It reminds us that loving someone and managing their emotional experience are two very different things.
I wonder how much lighter our Christmas celebrations might become if we remembered that distinction.
Perhaps we'd be less concerned about whether every detail went according to plan and more attentive to the people sitting across from us. We might even discover that some of the most meaningful moments happen when the schedule gets interrupted.
Making Room for Grace
There's a question I've found helpful when examining expectations. I think it's particularly appropriate as Christmas approaches.
What am I asking Christmas to give me that only Christ can ultimately provide?
For some of us, the answer may be a sense of belonging or reassurance that our families are doing well. For others, it may be the hope that a particular gathering will repair a relationship strained for years.
Those longings are understandable, and they often grow out of genuine love.
But even the most carefully planned Christmas cannot guarantee those outcomes. A holiday celebration can provide opportunities for connection and reconciliation. It cannot carry the full weight of our deepest emotional and spiritual needs.
That's where the invitation of Christ becomes so important. We can bring those longings to Him without pretending they don't matter. At the same time, we can recognize that our peace cannot depend entirely on whether Christmas unfolds according to our expectations.
This doesn't mean we stop planning, abandon our traditions, or become indifferent to the people we love. It means learning to hold our plans with a little more humility and our relationships with a little more grace.
Sometimes that requires a practical decision. Perhaps the gathering needs to be smaller this year, or the menu simpler. Maybe we need to ask for help instead of silently resenting the fact that nobody volunteered.
And sometimes we need to recognize that Christmas dinner probably isn't the best setting for settling a family disagreement that's been simmering since Easter.
Giving ourselves permission to make those adjustments isn't a failure of hospitality or love. It may be one of the wiser ways we can express both.
One Expectation Worth Releasing
As you prepare for the coming weeks, think about one expectation that's already creating pressure in your life. It might involve a family gathering, a longstanding tradition, or something you desperately hope will happen before the year ends.
Try finishing this sentence:
For Christmas to be good, this has to happen.
Then spend a little time considering whether that statement is really true. Is it a reasonable hope, or have you turned it into a requirement for your own peace of mind?
What might change if you loosened your grip on that expectation while continuing to care about the people involved?
You don't need to abandon every tradition or lower every expectation. Sometimes the most meaningful adjustment is recognizing that the people we love, including ourselves, are imperfect human beings who need room to breathe.
As I think back over the Christmases I've experienced, some of the most meaningful moments weren't the ones anyone carefully planned. They were ordinary moments of laughter, kindness, conversation, and occasionally something going wrong that eventually became part of the family story.
Perhaps that's worth remembering as we head into another Christmas season.
Christmas doesn't have to be perfect to be deeply meaningful. Sometimes its deepest moments are the ones we never planned.
A Little Hope for the Holidays
If you're looking for encouragement this Christmas, I've prepared a free printable guide, A Little Hope for the Holidays. It offers practical, Scripture-centered suggestions for navigating the season with greater peace, perspective, and hope.
Get your free Hope for the Holidays guide
You can also text LIGHT to 33777 to request your copy by email.
I'd be glad to stay connected and share more Resilient Faith encouragement with you throughout the year.
Coming next in our Hope for the Holidays series: Finding the Hope That Holds. We'll explore the difference between hoping for a particular outcome and placing our hope in the One who remains faithful, whatever happens.